Tottenville sits at the southern tip of New York State, with the Arthur Kill on one side and Raritan Bay on the other. That location gives the neighborhood its character, from the Victorian homes on the older blocks off Amboy Road and Main Street to the newer houses toward Page Avenue. It also means fences here deal with more wind, salt air and moisture than most yards in the city.
All Island Fence & Railing has been installing fences for more than 35 years, and we bring that experience to every project in the 10307 ZIP code. Whether you want a private backyard, a safe space for kids and pets, or a front fence that suits an older house, our team handles the whole job, from the first measurement to the final cleanup.
Homes close to Conference House Park and Tottenville Beach catch steady wind off the water, and salt air is hard on the wrong materials. Untreated steel rusts, and lower-grade wood can warp and turn gray within a few seasons.
That’s why so many Tottenville homeowners choose vinyl privacy fencing or powder-coated aluminum. PVC won’t rot, rust or need painting, and our PVC products carry a lifetime material warranty against manufacturer’s defects. Aluminum gives you an open, elegant look that holds up well close to salt water, which makes it a strong choice for yards that face the bay.
Wind matters as much as salt. A solid privacy panel catches far more wind than a semi-privacy or picket design, so we’ll talk through how much privacy you actually need and where you need it.
Tottenville has some of the best-preserved Victorian architecture on Staten Island, and a fence should add to that look, not fight it. A white picket fence or a classic aluminum design with simple finials sits naturally in front of a porch with turned columns and decorative trim.
If you prefer a natural look, our cedar and spruce wood fences come in picket, semi-privacy and full privacy styles. Wood does need staining or sealing every few years here, especially on the side facing the water.
For homes with front steps or a wraparound porch, matching aluminum railings can tie the fence and the house together.
Plenty of Tottenville backyards have a pool, and every pool needs a proper barrier with gates that close and latch on their own. Aluminum pool fencing is a popular choice because you can still see the pool area from the house and the deck. We plan the layout around your patio, pool equipment and the path you walk every day, then install the gate hardware so it works the way it should. We’ll also go over the pool barrier requirements that apply to your property before we finalize the design.
Every project starts with a free on-site estimate. We measure the property line, check slopes, and ask how you use the yard. You get a clear quote with the material, height, gates and layout spelled out, so there are no surprises.
Before we dig, all public utility lines are marked, including electric, gas and water.
Our installers are fully licensed and insured, and they set every post at the proper depth.
When the work is done, we clean up and walk the fence line with you.
Every installation is backed by our five-year labor warranty, in addition to the manufacturer warranties on the materials.
PVC and powder-coated aluminum are the two we recommend most in Tottenville. Neither one rusts or rots in salt air, and both stay looking good with little more than an occasional rinse. Wood works too, but it needs regular staining or sealing.
Yes. Fence replacement is one of the most common jobs we do here. We take down the old fence and posts, then install your new fence along the same line or a new layout, often in a different material or height.
Book a free on-site estimate. We’ll measure your yard, go over materials and gates, and give you a written quote.
Want to know more about materials and timelines first? Read our guide to fence installation on Staten Island.
Ready to get started? Call (516) 442-0012 or request your free estimate online. Tell us a little about your yard, and we’ll set up a visit at a time that works for you.
